Are protein bars good for weight loss?

Protein bars are often marketed as healthy, leaving many wondering about using protein bars for weight loss. But nutritionally, some protein bars are closer to candy bars in disguise. If you want to eat protein bars for weight loss, it’s important to understand what to look for, and how they may fit into a larger weight loss strategy.

Protein bars may help support weight loss, but only if you’re choosing the right ones and they are part of a more comprehensive diet strategy. To lose weight, you’ll need to make other dietary changes to ensure you’re in a calorie deficit, meaning you burn more calories than you consume.  

Protein is a key part of a weight loss diet. The high protein content in protein bars promotes feelings of fullness (since protein takes longer to digest than carbs), which can curb your appetite and prevent overeating, says Seth Kipnis, MD, a bariatric surgeon.

“Real food is far better for weight loss and health than any protein bars,” Dr. Kipnis says. “That said, protein bars can be a beneficial tool for weight loss when chosen carefully and integrated into a balanced diet and active lifestyle.”

Ideally, most of your protein should come from high-protein foods such as  poultry, eggs, fish, dairy, soy, and legumes, with beef and pork consumed occasionally. If you’re having trouble reaching your protein goals, you can supplement whole food protein intake with protein bars.

“Protein bars offer a convenient, portion-controlled snack or occasional meal replacement, making it easier to manage calorie intake, especially on busy days,” Dr. Kipnes says. 

See if you qualify

When choosing the best protein bars for weight loss, it’s far more important to read the label and check the ingredients than to rely on brand names alone.

The most weight loss-friendly protein bars tend to share a few key characteristics, according to Dr. Kipnes:

• High protein content: A good protein bar should contain around 10 to 20 grams of protein per serving to keep you feeling full and support muscle maintenance. 

• Good fiber content: Fiber supports weight loss by promoting feelings of fullness. Plus, it helps support digestion. Dr. Kipnes suggests choosing a protein bar with at least 3 grams of fiber.

• Low sugar content: Added sugar in protein bars can derail weight loss efforts. When you consume excess sugar, it's converted into fat and stored in your body. Check the label and aim for bars with low sugar content. 

• Healthy ingredients: Look for whole food ingredients and short ingredient lists. Longer lists and names you can’t pronounce or don’t recognize generally signal ultra-processed options with whopping doses of preservatives. 

Protein bars that meet these criteria are more likely to support weight loss rather than sabotage it. They should still be consumed within the context of a balanced diet that includes  plenty of whole foods such as fruits, vegetables, lean proteins, and whole grains.

It’s important to read the labels on protein bars to ensure that the ingredients are healthy and meet your dietary needs. Here are five tips to follow when you go shopping to find the best protein bars for weight loss.

1. Check the protein amount and source

Make sure the protein bar has at least 10 grams of protein, ideally more. You can also go based on your specific protein intake goals.

But not all protein is created equal, and it’s a good idea to know where the protein is coming from. Common protein sources in protein bars include:

• Milk proteins (whey and casein)

• Soy protein

• Pea protein

• Rice protein

• Egg white protein

Nuts and oats may also add some protein but are not as protein-rich as the primary protein sources. 

Be cautious of dietary concerns when choosing the protein source. For example, if you’re lactose intolerant, you may want to avoid whey and casein since they’re derived from milk.

2. Look for whole food ingredients

A protein bar isn’t a whole food, but you’ll want to find protein bars made with whole foods. Dr. Kipnes suggests prioritizing protein bars with whole-food ingredients (like nuts, seeds, and oats) at the top of the ingredient list. 

3. Check the fiber content

Since fiber can help promote feelings of fullness, Dr. Kipnes recommends eating protein bars that contain at least 3 to 5 grams of fiber if you’re incorporating protein bars for weight loss. 

4. Check the sugar content 

You want minimal added sugars to keep the calorie content lower. “Many bars on the market are high in calories, sugar, and fat, essentially making them glorified candy bars that can contribute to weight gain if not accounted for in one's daily calorie budget,” Dr. Kipnes says.

But when looking for low sugar options, watch out for sugar alcohols, which can cause bloating and gas in some people, he warns. Examples of sugar alcohols are erythritol, xylitol, mannitol, and sorbitol.

5. Avoid long ingredient lists and long shelf lives

When a protein bar (or any other food) has a long ingredient list and/or very long shelf life, it’s often an indication that there are many added processed ingredients, Dr. Kipnes says. Instead, opt for bars with shorter ingredient lists (preferably prioritizing whole foods) and shorter shelf lives. 

Before adding protein bars to your weight loss plan, it’s important to understand a few potential considerations. 

• Calories still count: Protein bars can contribute to weight gain if eaten frequently without accounting for total daily calories. Check the label for added sugars, which are notorious for adding empty calories.

• You shouldn’t overrely on them: Protein bars should supplement a healthy diet, but shouldn’t be the main source of your nutrition. “Relying too heavily on protein bars may lead to a lower intake of the wide array of micronutrients and beneficial compounds found in whole foods,” Dr. Kipnes says.

• They don’t have as many nutrients as whole foods: Although protein bars can provide protein and fiber, they aren’t very nutrient dense. “The highly processed nature of many protein bars means they lack the full nutritional benefits of whole foods,” Dr. Kipnes says.

Protein bars are generally meant to be used as snacks between meals and to boost protein intake, while meal replacement bars are designed to replace a full meal. 

Protein bars:

• Purpose: Eat them as a snack or a source of supplemental protein.

• Nutritional profile: They usually have a solid protein content and typically lower carb and calorie counts than meal replacement bars.

• Best for: People who want an easy, filling snack throughout the day or after a workout, or those looking to increase protein intake to build muscle. 

Meal replacement bars:

• Purpose: Eat them as a replacement for a full meal. 

• Nutritional profile: On top of providing protein, they also include other macros and nutrients, since they’re meant to nutritionally mimic a real meal. The calorie content is typically higher than the calorie content in protein bars for this reason. 

• Best for: People who are having a busy day and don’t have time to prepare a healthy meal, or need to eat something on the go. 

As for which one is better for weight loss, Dr. Kipnes says neither one is inherently superior. “The better choice depends on the individual's immediate need — a satisfying snack to bridge meals or a more complete nutritional substitute for a meal,” he says. 

No matter which one you choose, make sure you still eat plenty of nutritious whole foods and stay in a calorie deficit if your goal is weight loss. 

Check for free

Protein bars can be a helpful weight loss tool, but they work best as part of a balanced weight loss regimen.

• Protein bars can help you lose weight as long as you are also eating a healthy diet and maintaining a calorie deficit.

• Opt for healthy protein bars with at least 10 grams of protein, 3 to 5 grams of fiber, minimal added sugar, and whole food ingredients.

• Meal replacement bars are a more nutrient-dense and higher-calorie option. They are better suited for fully replacing a meal rather than serving as a snack.